How This Index Works
Every costs decision covered on this site, grouped by what it actually decides rather than by date. Each entry gives the citation, the point, and a link to the full note.
These are written from the judgments and revised when a decision is overturned. That matters more in costs than it sounds: the conduct-of-litigation line below reversed completely on appeal, and material still describing the first-instance position as good law is not merely dated but wrong.
Who May Do Costs Work
CILEX and others v Mazur and others [2026] EWCA Civ 369
Court of Appeal, 31 March 2026. An unauthorised person may lawfully carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation for and on behalf of an authorised individual who retains direction, control and responsibility. Supervision must be real and proportionate. This overturned the September 2025 High Court ruling that had held the opposite. Read the note.
The Bill Itself
Duffy v Birmingham City Council [2026] EWCA Civ 146
Court of Appeal. A defective indemnity-principle certification does not automatically invalidate service of the bill; CPR 3.10 can cure procedural error, and the paying party is expected to engage rather than lie in wait. Not a licence to serve a defective bill. Read the note.
The Winros Partnership v Global Energy Horizons Corporation [2026] EWCA Civ 654
Court of Appeal, 22 May 2026. A solicitor who accepted the client’s repudiatory breach of a CFA could not recover on a quantum meruit: where the agreement addressed termination, no different basis could be implied. A Solicitors Act solicitor-client dispute rather than an inter partes authority, but it completes the entitlement picture — the retainer is where recoverability begins. Read the note.
HD & Ors v North Devon Healthcare Trust & Ors [2026] EWHC 2009 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office, 4 August 2026. The CFA covered negotiation or assessment of the costs, so completing the costs process was part of the retainer. The solicitor abandoned the claims, the retainers became unenforceable, and with no liability to their own solicitor the claimants had nothing to recover. Six assessments struck out, alternatively assessed at nil, £92,000 in payments on account repaid, CPR 47.8 unless orders for the wider cohort and CPR 44.11 orders against the former solicitor. Read the note.
Kapoor v Johal [2024] EWHC 2853 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office. A bill claiming £258,583.78 assessed at nil under CPR 44.11 where the client had been invoiced around £84,000. The indemnity principle is a ceiling, and a bill that does not reconcile with the interim statute bills puts the whole claim at risk rather than a line of it. Read the note.
Ward v Rai [2026] EWCA Civ 816
Court of Appeal, 2 July 2026. A Costs Judge who declined to strike out a vague point of dispute, and allowed an annotated schedule served two working days before the hearing, was within the generous ambit of his discretion. PD 47 para 8.2 still requires an Ainsworth compliant approach; what moved is the consequence of ignoring it. Read the note.
LM1 Limited v Seacroft Film Investments Limited [2026] EWHC 2212 (Ch)
High Court, 21 August 2026. A £74,075.60 bill was struck out for claiming the costs of the whole action where the entitlement was to the counterclaim alone. Under Medway Oil only the costs specifically referable to the counterclaim are recoverable — the rest are claim costs and are not apportioned. The redrawn bill of £46,755.35 was called astonishing, and the receiving party then won its application and recovered no costs at all. Read the note.
Ian Henderson & Anor v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2645 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office, 16 October 2026. Without prejudice costs breakdowns, served in settled MoD NIHL claims primarily to support interim payments, were higher than the certified bills. The MoD could not rely on them: the difference fell a long way short of the unambiguous impropriety needed to displace privilege, and of any CPR 44.11 misconduct, though the court said more could have been done to rationalise the costs. Read the note.
Turner v Coupland Cavendish Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1204
Court of Appeal, 21 September 2026. In a section 70 Solicitors Act assessment the costs judge has no power to order the solicitor to answer Part 18 questions about commission on an ATE premium: the assessment is of the bill, and the cash account is used only to see what has been paid and held, not opened to that kind of challenge. The client can still ask, seek an account or complain to the Legal Ombudsman. Read the note.
Disbursements and Expert Fees
JXX v Archibald [2026] EWHC 630 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office. Medical reporting organisation charges are disbursements rather than outsourced profit costs, and a 25% mark-up was allowed on the evidence. It is a first-instance benchmark that paying parties now deploy, not a statutory cap. Read the note.
Under appeal. JXX and MIB v Santiago are listed in the Court of Appeal two days apart in March 2027, both on how much of an agency charge is recoverable and what must be disclosed to justify it. Anything built on the 25% figure should be treated as provisional until then — what the appeals could decide.
Money Before Assessment
Magomedov v Rabinovich [2026] EWHC 962 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office, 24 April 2026. No jurisdiction to order security for the costs of a detailed assessment under CPR 25: CPR 47 is a self-contained code with no express importation of CPR 25, and a receiving party is not a defendant to the costs claim. The interim costs certificate under CPR 47.16 is the mechanism the regime does provide. Read the note.
Cubic Transportation Systems Ltd v Transport for London [2026] EWHC 211 (TCC)
Technology and Construction Court, 5 February 2026. There is no fixed percentage for a payment on account. The amount turns on the costs claimed measured against the court’s provisional view of what is reasonable and proportionate, and on the quality of the information provided. TfL sought 60% of £1,201,444.75 and got all of it, because the judge had “no doubt” it would recover at least that on assessment. Read the note.
Município de Mariana v BHP Group (UK) Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1319
Court of Appeal, 16 October 2026. Interest on costs from before judgment under CPR 44.2(6)(g) can be awarded to claimants funded under conditional fee agreements who have paid nothing, because they are liable, through their success fees, to compensate their solicitors for providing legal services on credit. The award is not a recovery of the success fee, so section 58A(6) of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 and Hirachand v Hirachand do not prevent it. Interest at 1% above base rate, from the date by which half of the fees had been incurred, was upheld. Read the note.
Partial Success and Issue-Based Costs Orders
JBX v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust (Costs) [2026] EWHC 2525 (KB)
King’s Bench Division, 5 October 2026. A clinical negligence claimant who lost the principal issue at an eight-day trial, future care and accommodation, still recovered 85% of his costs. He was the successful party overall, it had not been unreasonable to run the care case to trial, considerable expert costs were incurred before the issue crystallised, and the Trust made no Part 36 offer. Conduct criticisms with no identified costs consequences carried little weight. Read the note.
JXX v Archibald (costs) [2026] EWHC 2404 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office, 18 September 2026. The consequential costs judgment in the MRO fees litigation. The claimants and MROs were the successful parties on the general MRO issues and recovered those costs without a percentage reduction, despite an approximately 40% reduction to the MRO fees in HLA. The Defendant recovered the costs of the disclosure application, the costs go to detailed assessment if not agreed, and no payment on account was ordered while the substantive decision is under appeal. Read the note.
Conduct and the Basis of Assessment
The New Lottery Company Ltd v The Gambling Commission [2026] EWHC 1311 (TCC)
Technology and Construction Court, 22 May 2026. Indemnity costs awarded for the entirety of proceedings after issues were abandoned wholesale and serious allegations dropped. Proportionality is not a relevant factor in deciding whether to order indemnity costs, and once ordered the paying party forfeits proportionality arguments at assessment. Read the note.
Part 36 and Timing
Timokhin v Timokhina [2026] EWHC 1194 (KB)
King’s Bench Division, 19 May 2026. An offer at 91% of the claim was a genuine attempt to settle under CPR 36.17(5)(e), because the claimant had a rational basis for regarding his prospects as strong. Binariness in a recognition and enforcement claim did not make a high offer improper. There is no percentage threshold, and the party resisting the consequences faces a formidable obstacle. Read the note.
Attersley v UK Insurance Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 217
Court of Appeal, 24 March 2026. A Part 36 offer accepted 16 months late, after the claim had been allocated to the multi-track. The costs regime was fixed by the expiry of the relevant period, not by the date of acceptance, because Part 36 is a self-contained code in which certainty is essential. Concerns the pre-October 2023 regime, and expressly leaves two timing combinations undecided. Read the note.
Lintern v Haven Insurance Company Ltd [2026] EWHC 2478 (KB)
King’s Bench Division, 28 July 2026. A defendant’s £5,000 Part 36 offer in a fast track fixed costs claim was accepted 11 months late, on the first day of trial. Once the claim has moved to a later stage, CPR 36.23(8) produces a single order for the defendant: its fixed costs at acceptance less the claimant’s at expiry, with no separate order for the claimant. The judge called it a tricky issue, but the wording decided it. Read the note.
Cleveland Potash Ltd v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP)
Business and Property Division, 30 October 2026. Beating the money in a Part 36 offer is not enough where the offer is a package. The applicant secured a lower rent than its own offer proposed, but had not shown that the outcome beat the offer as a whole, so the CPR 36.17 consequences were refused, and they would have been unjust in any event. £550,000 was ordered on account of £1,204,160.86 claimed. Read the note.
Ashi Group Ltd v Daniels [2026] EWCC 68
County Court at Bristol, 12 November 2026 (persuasive, not binding). A Precedent U served about 19 hours before a fast track trial, not the 24 hours CPR 45.63(2) requires, did not cost the claimant its fixed costs. The rule states no sanction and carries no implied one, so CPR 3.9 relief was never the test: the court responds proportionately (Macdonald v Taree), and where the lateness caused no prejudice it assesses the costs in the normal way. Read the note.
Entitlement and the Route to Recovery
Alphabet (UK) Ltd v AXA Insurance UK Plc [2026] EWHC 674 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office, 23 March 2026. Issuing proceedings to recover pre-action costs a defendant refuses to pay is not an abuse, and the test for instructing solicitors is reasonableness rather than necessity, judged when the decision was taken. The claimant won both points and recovered £599 against £1,006.80 claimed, because fixed costs governed the sum. A Part 7 claim, not CPR 46.14. Read the note.
Recovery in Specific Claim Types
Smith v Wigan Borough Council [2026] EWHC 660 (SCCO)
Senior Courts Costs Office. A £1,000 housing disrepair settlement does not automatically restrict costs to small claims track levels under CPR 46.13. The question is what the claim was reasonably worth on the evidence, and the evidential burden sits with the paying party. Read the note.
Orton v Barclays Bank UK Plc [2026] EWCA Civ 1025
Court of Appeal. On the small claims track, discontinuing a claim is not in itself unreasonable behaviour under CPR 27.14(2)(g). The party alleging unreasonableness must prove it against a costs-neutral starting point, and a letter that only invites the other side to discontinue is not an offer. Read the note.
Harvey v Heaver [2026] EWHC 1671 (KB)
King’s Bench Division, 3 July 2026. After an expedited trial, a rented family home was held unfit for human habitation under section 9A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, and the landlord was ordered to carry out the works. Indemnity costs were refused: the costs of the trial on the standard basis, with £130,000 plus VAT on account against an approved budget of £180,000 plus VAT. Read the note.
Ritchie v The Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2026] EWCC 50
County Court, 18 August 2026. An in-life settlement with the manufacturer of a heater-cooler unit was full satisfaction, so the widow’s Fatal Accidents Act claim against the trust failed. The court entered summary judgment rather than striking the claim out, which kept her QOCS protection: a strike-out on the CPR 44.15 grounds would have let the trust enforce its costs in full without permission. Read the note.
Abbott v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 941 (KB)
King’s Bench Division. The substantive military NIHL decision on quantification method, audiograms, tinnitus and de minimis, and what it means for how a MoD NIHL bill should be built. Read the note.
Abbott v Ministry of Defence (costs) [2026] EWHC 2083 (KB)
King’s Bench Division. 60% of common costs, the arithmetic behind a £2.5m payment on account, and why the quality of the costs documentation put before the court directly affected the interim award. Read the note.
Practice Guides That Apply These Decisions
The decisions above are applied in our working guides: the 2026 guideline hourly rates for solicitors, the N260 and summary assessment, MoD NIHL costs after a Matrix settlement and the current civil court fees. For the terms, forms and dates these decisions turn on, see the legal costs glossary, the costs forms and precedents guide and the detailed assessment deadline calculator. Our free costs order meanings decoder explains what the costs orders themselves mean, from costs in the case to the indemnity basis.
What This Index Does Not Do
It does not pretend to be every costs decision of the year. It is the set this practice has read in full and written up, which is a smaller and more useful thing than a digest assembled from headnotes. Where a case is not here, we have not covered it rather than judged it unimportant.
How DMD Costs Can Help
We prepare and negotiate claimant costs for solicitor firms in housing disrepair, MoD NIHL and clinical negligence. If a decision above bears on a live file, or you want a bill or budget prepared, send us the file and we will confirm a fixed fee before any work begins.