Costs Negotiation for Claimant Solicitor Firms
A bill of costs is an opening position. What a firm recovers is decided after the Points of Dispute arrive: which objections are conceded, which are answered, what is offered and when. We negotiate claimant costs through that stage for the instructing firm, from the Points of Dispute and the paying party’s open offer to an agreed figure.
We prepare the costs documentation and support your team through the process. The instructing solicitor retains conduct of the matter.
What does a costs negotiator do?
A costs negotiator works to agree the costs one party pays another without a hearing. For a claimant firm that means answering the paying party’s Points of Dispute, making and testing offers, and settling the bill at a realistic recoverable figure, while the instructing solicitor keeps conduct of the claim and decides on every offer.
- Reading the bill against the Points of Dispute and the paying party’s open offer, to see which disputes carry the money.
- Preparing the Replies, limited to points of principle and concessions.
- Making, answering and recording offers: open, Part 36 and “without prejudice save as to costs”.
- Negotiating towards an agreed figure on the firm’s instructions, with the assessment deadlines in view.
Where Negotiation Starts
The paying party has 21 days from service of the notice of commencement to serve Points of Dispute (CPR 47.9(2)). With them comes an open letter stating what sum, if any, it offers in settlement of the total costs claimed (PD 47 para 8.3). A separate Part 36 offer may be made as well, and the two carry different consequences; our Part 36 calculator tests an offer against the assessed figure. Our detailed assessment deadline calculator works out these dates, including deemed service and bank holidays.
The open letter is the most useful document in the pack. Points of Dispute can run to dozens of individual reductions; the open offer says what they mean commercially. So the first question on any file is the gap between the bill and that offer, and which Points account for most of it. If no Points of Dispute are served in time, a default costs certificate may be available under CPR 47.11, so the expiry date matters as much as the content.
How We Negotiate
- Value the dispute before answering it. Rates and grades, time on documents, counsel, experts and disbursements do not carry equal money, and the Reply should follow the money.
- Concede what should be conceded. It narrows the dispute, the court sees it later, and it makes the rest of the Reply credible.
- Reply on principle. A Reply is optional and due within 21 days (CPR 47.13). It is limited to points of principle and concessions; general denials, specific denials and standard-form responses are not allowed (PD 47 para 12.1).
- Make offers that count. The receiving party is generally entitled to the costs of the detailed assessment proceedings (CPR 47.20), but that is a starting point, and Part 36 applies to detailed assessment proceedings with modifications. A well-pitched offer, made early and beaten at assessment, changes who pays for the assessment itself.
- Keep the offers distinct. The open offer and any Part 36 offer are recorded separately, with the amount and date of each, in both directions.
The question behind every step is commercial: what is the realistic recoverable figure, and which disputes stand between the firm and it?
What Gets Argued
On any assessment the court will not allow costs which have been unreasonably incurred or are unreasonable in amount (CPR 44.3(1)). On the standard basis it also allows only costs that are proportionate to the matters in issue, may disallow or reduce disproportionate costs even if they were reasonably or necessarily incurred, and resolves any doubt in the paying party’s favour (CPR 44.3(2)).
Costs are proportionate if they bear a reasonable relationship to the sums in issue, the value of any non-monetary relief, the complexity of the litigation, any additional work generated by the paying party’s conduct, any wider factors such as reputation or public importance, and any additional work or expense due to the vulnerability of a party or witness (CPR 44.3(5)). In deciding the amount, the court has regard to all the circumstances, including the conduct of all the parties, the complexity of the matter, the skill, effort and specialised knowledge involved, the time spent and the receiving party’s last approved or agreed budget (CPR 44.4). Within that framework, Points of Dispute keep returning to the same items:
- Hourly rates. The rates claimed are measured against the guideline hourly rates for each fee earner’s grade; our guide to the 2026 guideline hourly rates sets out every band and grade. On our reading, a case for a rate above the guideline rests on the factors in CPR 44.4(3), such as the complexity of the matter and the specialised knowledge involved.
- Time spent on documents. Document time is tested item by item: what each document was, why it took the time claimed and whether the grade of fee earner suited it.
- Counsel’s and experts’ fees. These are challenged on necessity and amount. Copies of counsel’s and experts’ fee notes are served with the notice of commencement (PD 47 para 5.2(c)), so the Reply can show what each fee paid for.
- The ATE premium. In the claims we work on, a costs order cannot include any part of an after-the-event insurance premium for a policy taken out on or after 1 April 2013 (section 58C(1) of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990, in force from that date; Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, s 46(3)), with one exception: in clinical negligence, where the claim for damages is worth more than £1,000, the part of the premium that insures against the cost of expert reports on liability or causation (regulation 3 of the Recovery of Costs Insurance Premiums in Clinical Negligence Proceedings (No. 2) Regulations 2013). The policy must itself state how much of the premium relates to expert reports (section 58C(2)(d)), and paying parties often dispute how the recoverable part was worked out.
Part 36 or a Calderbank offer?
A Part 36 offer can decide who pays for the assessment itself and, on our reading, so can a Calderbank offer. The receiving party is entitled to the costs of the detailed assessment proceedings unless the rules provide otherwise or the court makes some other order; in deciding whether to make one, the court must have regard to all the circumstances, including the conduct of all the parties and the amount, if any, by which the bill has been reduced (CPR 47.20(1) and (3)).
A Part 36 offer must be in writing, make clear that it is made under Part 36, specify a period of not less than 21 days (the relevant period), state whether it relates to the whole of the claim or to part of it or an issue, and state whether it takes into account any counterclaim (CPR 36.5(1)). Part 36 applies to the costs of detailed assessment proceedings with modifications: the receiving party takes the claimant’s place, the detailed assessment hearing the trial’s, and the completion of the assessment the judgment’s (CPR 47.20(4)). For the purposes of CPR 36.17, the assessment proceedings are treated as an independent claim (CPR 47.20(7)).
If the receiving party fails to beat the paying party’s offer, the court must, unless it considers it unjust, order that the paying party is entitled to its costs from the end of the relevant period, with interest on them (CPR 36.17(3)). If the assessment is at least as good for the receiving party as its own offer, the court must, unless unjust, order the consequences in CPR 36.17(4): interest of up to 10% above base rate on the sum awarded, indemnity costs with interest, and an additional amount.
A Calderbank offer, made “without prejudice save as to costs”, sits outside Part 36, so it does not have Part 36’s consequences (CPR 36.2(2)). The court has regard to it instead, as an admissible offer that is not a Part 36 offer (CPR 44.2(4)(c)); on our reading, it is one of the circumstances weighed under CPR 47.20(3). In a provisional assessment, offers marked “without prejudice save as to costs” or made under Part 36 are filed in a sealed envelope (PD 47 para 14.3(d)).
Whichever form is used, an offer should say whether it includes the cost of preparing the bill and VAT, and an offer outside Part 36 whether it includes interest; if it does not, it is treated as including all of them (PD 47 para 19). On our reading, Part 36 is the stronger tool where the figure is right, because its consequences are set by the rules; a Calderbank offer leaves more room on terms, but what it achieves is left to the court.
Interim Payments While Talks Go On
A long negotiation need not mean waiting for all of the money. Where the court orders a party to pay costs subject to detailed assessment, it will order that party to pay a reasonable sum on account of costs, unless there is good reason not to (CPR 44.2(8)). Once the receiving party has filed a request for a detailed assessment hearing, the court may also issue an interim costs certificate for such sum as it considers appropriate (CPR 47.16(1)), on an application under Part 23 (PD 47 para 15); the certificate includes an order to pay unless the court orders otherwise (CPR 47.16(2)). We prepare the costs information behind a request or an application for either.
Budgets and Schedules Too
Negotiation is not only for the final bill. Where costs budgets are exchanged, the other parties must file an agreed budget discussion report no later than 7 days before the first case management conference (CPR 3.13(2)). It sets out the figures agreed for each phase, those not agreed and a brief summary of the grounds of dispute, and the parties are encouraged to use Precedent R for it (PD 3D para 11). Agreement counts: a costs management order records the extent to which the budgeted costs are agreed, and the court approves the rest after making appropriate revisions (CPR 3.15(2)). We prepare the Precedent H budget and the Precedent R report and, on your instructions, negotiate the phases before the CCMC; the hearing itself is for the instructing firm, counsel or a Costs Lawyer. More on how we prepare costs budgets.
Statements of costs work the same way. For a hearing at which costs may be summarily assessed, each party who intends to claim costs must prepare a statement of them, following Form N260 as closely as possible, and file and serve it not less than 24 hours before the hearing, or 2 days before a fast track trial (PD 44 para 9.5). Where the parties to an application agree an order by consent without attending, they should seek to agree a figure for costs to go in it or agree that there should be no order for costs (PD 44 para 9.4). We prepare the N260 and, on your instructions, negotiate the figure where it can be agreed before the hearing.
If the Costs Do Not Settle
A request for a detailed assessment hearing must be filed within three months of the expiry of the period for commencing detailed assessment proceedings (CPR 47.14). Where the costs claimed are £75,000 or less, the bill is provisionally assessed (PD 47 para 14.1). If the proceedings go no further than provisional assessment, the most the court will award as the costs of the assessment, other than the cost of drafting the bill, is £1,500 plus VAT and court fees (CPR 47.15(5)). That cap is worth having in mind when deciding whether a remaining gap is worth an assessment. The deadlines at every stage are set out in our costs recovery checklist.
If a bill goes to a contested hearing, we arrange the advocate (counsel or a Costs Lawyer) and prepare the papers. If you are deciding between a costs draftsman and a Costs Lawyer, see costs draftsman or Costs Lawyer: which you actually need.
Negotiation Across Our Three Practice Areas
The arguments differ by claim type. In housing disrepair costs they turn on surveyor fees, client contact and proportionality; in MoD NIHL costs, on the work the file actually needed after a Matrix settlement; in clinical negligence costs, on experts, counsel and the approved budget. The common reductions are set out for housing disrepair Points of Dispute and for clinical negligence Points of Dispute and Replies.
Our Costs Negotiators
The work stays with the practitioners named on the file.
- Diellza Nika Hyseni, law costs draftsperson and Managing Director: 15+ years in legal costs. She leads clinical negligence costs and costs budgeting and negotiates both, and all clinical negligence and budgeting work is subject to her senior technical review.
- Mentor Nika, law costs draftsman and Head of Housing Disrepair Costs: 6+ years in claimant legal costs. He leads housing disrepair and MoD NIHL costs and negotiates them from the Points of Dispute to settlement.
We do not publish case results we have not produced. Across our settled files, average recovery is above 70% of the bill as drafted. Beyond that, what we offer as evidence is named responsibility for the work and published guidance you can check against the rules yourself.
Fixed Fee Agreed Before Instructions
The fee is fixed and agreed before any work begins. Negotiation to settlement is part of it, alongside the bill and the Points of Dispute and Replies. Unless we agree otherwise in writing, our agreed fee is payable when your firm receives the recovered costs from the paying party.