How to use the bill of costs builder
- Check that a paper bill may be used. Answer two questions about the claim. If PD 47 para 5.1 requires an electronic bill, the builder says so and points you to the J-code and Precedent S lookup instead.
- Fill in the title page and background. The court, the parties, whose bill it is, the order showing the right to assessment, the VAT number, a brief history of the proceedings and the funding arrangement.
- Set the fee earners and parts. Each fee earner’s status and hourly rate, with any change of rate from a date; then the parts of the bill by date and funding, each with its basis of assessment.
- Enter the items. Timed work, routine letters, e-mails and calls, disbursements and the relevant events, in any order. The builder sorts them by part, head and date, numbers them and builds the schedules.
- Choose the certificates and download. Pick the Precedent F certificates that apply, preview the bill and download it as a Word file. Check it, sign the certificates and serve it with the notice of commencement.
When an electronic bill is required instead
PD 47 para 5.1 sets out when a bill must be electronic, in these words:
The circumstances in which bills of costs must be electronic bills are that— (a) the case is a Part 7 multi-track claim, except— (i) for cases in which the proceedings are subject to fixed costs or scale costs; (ii) cases in which the receiving party is unrepresented; or (iii) where the court has otherwise ordered; and (b) the bills of costs relate to costs recoverable between the parties for work undertaken after 6 April 2018 (“the Transition Date”).
In all other circumstances the bill may be electronic or on paper (para 5.1). Where the work straddles the Transition Date, the work before it may be in a paper or an electronic bill and the work after it must be in an electronic bill (para 5.A4). An electronic bill is Precedent S (blank template on justice.gov.uk) or any spreadsheet meeting para 5.A2, served in hard copy and as the spreadsheet (para 5.1A). If yours must be electronic, the builder says so and does not make a paper bill: use our J-code and Precedent S code lookup to code the work, and see Precedent S in clinical negligence claims for the transition date in practice.
How a Precedent A bill is laid out
A bill may consist of such of these sections as are appropriate (PD 47 para 5.7), and the download follows the same order, as in Precedent A:
- Title page (para 5.10): the court and claim number, the parties, “Claimant’s bill of costs to be assessed pursuant to the order dated …”, the VAT number and any legal aid certificates.
- Background information (para 5.11): the history of the proceedings, the funding arrangement, each fee earner’s status and hourly rate (with any change of rate), and who conducted the case except where the bill says otherwise.
- The items, part by part, under the heads of para 5.12, in columns for item number, description, VAT, disbursements and profit costs (para 5.17). Relevant events, including costs orders, are noted without numbers (para 5.16). VAT on the profit costs of each part is claimed as the last item of the part, at 20% of the part’s profit costs, and VAT on a disbursement on the disbursement’s own line.
- The summary (para 5.20): VAT, disbursements and profit costs for each part, the totals, the total of profit costs and disbursements, the total VAT and the grand total.
- Schedules: any of heads (2) to (10) with 20 or more non-routine attendances and communications claims the total only and refers to a numbered schedule (para 5.18); work done on documents goes to a schedule too, as in Precedent A (Schedule 3). The bill claims the schedule’s total at a numbered item, and the schedule names that item.
- Certificates (para 5.21), in the wording of Precedent F.
Every item is rounded to the penny once, and every total is the sum of the printed figures, so the columns always add up. Precedent A claims VAT on the solicitors’ fees as an item at the end; the builder does the same for each part, so that VAT is worked out on each part’s own profit costs, and shows the VAT on each disbursement once, on the disbursement’s own line.
The basis of assessment
Costs are assessed on the standard or the indemnity basis, and on neither will the court allow costs unreasonably incurred or unreasonable in amount (CPR 44.3(1)). On the standard basis it allows only proportionate costs and resolves any doubt in favour of the paying party; on the indemnity basis it resolves doubt in favour of the receiving party (CPR 44.3(2) and (3)). An order that does not say which means the standard basis (CPR 44.3(4)). The factors the court takes into account are in CPR 44.4. Where costs are on different bases from a date, such as indemnity costs after a claimant beats its own Part 36 offer, give each basis its own part.
The certificates
Precedent F says that certificates (1) and (2) are required in all cases and (3) wherever the receiving party is legally aided; (4), (5) and (6) are optional. The builder prints the certificates in the precedent’s own words, filling in only its blanks and joining certificate (1)’s clauses where the funding differs between parts: the parts each funding covers, the rulings and payments for certificate (2) and the details of certificate (6). For work by a legal representative who is not an employee, certificate (1) confirms that the costs claimed do not exceed what the receiving party must pay. Words such as “me/my firm” and “has/has not” are left for the signatory to complete. The builder will not let certificate (6) say the VAT is recoverable while the bill claims it (PD 44 para 2.3).
What the builder does not do
It does not make an electronic bill, divide a bill by budget phase after a costs management order (PD 47 para 5.8(8) and (9)), handle VAT at rates other than 20% (the rate from 4 January 2011, Finance (No. 2) Act 2010, s.3), price a litigant in person’s own time (use the litigant in person costs calculator), or decide what is reasonable or proportionate. Nor does it claim a success fee or ATE premium recoverable under a funding arrangement made before 1 April 2013; set out costs claimed against the LSC or the Lord Chancellor only (PD 47 para 5.9, Precedents B and C); give the statement of reasons required where the bill is 20% or more above a filed budget and no costs management order was made (PD 44 para 3.2); or give a certificate (1) for each firm where more than one firm did the work (Precedent F). If you choose a guideline rates band and grade, it notes any rate above the guideline rate in force on the date of the work, as a prompt only; the free guideline hourly rates calculator gives the rates. Then serve the bill with the notice of commencement, which the N252 builder fills in, and follow detailed assessment step by step.
Sources
- CPR Part 47 (rules 47.6 and 47.7)
- Practice Direction 47 (paras 5.1 to 5.22 and 13.3), updated 6 April 2022
- Precedent A and Precedent F, Schedule of Costs Precedents annexed to PD 47
- CPR Part 44 (rules 44.3 and 44.4)
- Practice Direction 44 (paras 2.2 to 2.9, VAT)
- Finance (No. 2) Act 2010, s.3 (VAT at 20% from 4 January 2011)