How to use the clinical negligence letter of claim builder
- Choose the letter. Pick the Letter of Claim (Annex C2) or the Letter of Notification (Annex C1), and enter the date of the letter and when you expect it to be received.
- Enter the firm, the defendant and the claimant. Add your firm, the healthcare provider and who the letter is copied to, the claimant’s details, and the treatment or care, the place, any clinician and the dates.
- Set out what happened. Give the chronology from the medical records, an outline of events, the allegations of negligence one by one, and the causal link with the injuries.
- Describe the injuries and the value. Describe the injuries, condition and prognosis, rehabilitation and the expert disciplines, then the heads of damage, the scale of the loss and any ADR suggestion.
- Add records, funding and limitation. Choose the records index and the records requested, the method of funding and whether it pre-dates April 2013, and the last day for issue.
- Check and download. Work through the checks and the para 3.16 list, read the preview, then download the letter as a Word document or copy it as text.
What the letter of claim should contain (paras 3.14 to 3.19)
If, after the records and any further advice (including from experts) have been analysed, the claimant decides there are grounds for a claim, a letter of claim should be sent to the defendant as soon as practicable, and a letter to an NHS trust copied to the NHS Litigation Authority, now NHS Resolution (para 3.14). It should contain (para 3.16):
- (a) a clear summary of the facts on which the claim is based, including the alleged adverse outcome, and the main allegations of negligence;
- (b) a description of the claimant’s injuries, and present condition and prognosis;
- (c) an outline of the financial loss incurred by the claimant, with an indication of the heads of damage to be claimed and the scale of the loss, unless this is impracticable;
- (d) confirmation of the method of funding and whether any funding arrangement was entered into before or after April 2013; and
- (e) the discipline of any expert from whom evidence has already been obtained.
It should refer to any relevant documents, including health records, and if possible enclose copies of those the defendant will not already have (para 3.17). Enough must be given for the defendant to focus its investigations and put an initial valuation on the claim (para 3.18). A letter of claim does not have the formal status of Particulars of Claim, and sanctions need not follow if the two differ (para 3.19).
The Annex C templates
Annex C2 sets out the Letter of Claim under headings: the claimant’s details; the dates of the allegedly negligent treatment, with a chronology based on the medical records; the events giving rise to the claim; the allegations of negligence and the causal link with the injuries; the client’s injuries, condition and prognosis, with rehabilitation and the expert disciplines; the clinical records; the likely value of the claim, with any Part 36 offer and suggestions for ADR; and funding. It closes by giving the date the Letter of Response is due and saying the National Insurance number will follow separately, for the recovery of benefits.
Annex C1, the Letter of Notification, covers the same ground in outline, adds the date by which proceedings must be issued for limitation, and asks for an acknowledgment within 14 days. The templates are a guide to the recommended contents, and the level of detail varies with the case (paras 3.10 and 3.13).
The builder keeps each template’s fixed wording and turns its notes (“include chronology”, “(optional)”, “[State method of funding]”) into short sentences of its own from your answers. Our reading, where it departs from the printed text: “treatment carried out/care provided”, “breach of duty and/or causation” and “injuries/needs” are resolved from your answers; C1’s “failure to do may be taken into account” reads “failure to do so”; the claimant’s details are laid out as labelled lines; the clinician and the place are left out of C1’s “correct defendant” sentence when not known; C1 is given the addressee and greeting that C2 has; and C1’s note asking for an index of the records and a request for further records is filled with C2’s two clinical records paragraphs. The NHS Litigation Authority has been NHS Resolution since April 2017, so for an NHS trust in England the builder suggests NHS Resolution for the copy line. Para 3.14 requires a copy only for an NHS trust.
The acknowledgment and the Letter of Response (paras 3.22 to 3.29)
The defendant should acknowledge the letter of claim within 14 days of receipt and say who will deal with it (para 3.23), and within four months of the letter of claim give a reasoned Letter of Response, following template C3: whether the claim is admitted in whole or in part, which issues of breach of duty and causation are admitted or denied and why, whether admissions are binding, its version of any disputed events, the expert disciplines relied on and any other potential defendants (para 3.24). A request for more time should be made as soon as it is needed and within the four months, with reasons, and the claimant should take a reasonable approach (para 3.25). Count the dates with the pre-action protocol deadline calculator.
Limitation
The protocol does not alter the statutory time limits. If the four months cannot run before limitation expires, the claimant’s solicitor should give as much notice of issue as practicable, and the parties should apply for a stay while they comply (paras 1.6.1 and 3.20). Work out the date with the free limitation period calculator.
Costs
When a clinical negligence claim settles, the claimant’s costs are agreed or assessed. Budget them with the Precedent H builder, and read our guide to budgets, Precedent H and the CCMC.
Sources
- Pre-Action Protocol for the Resolution of Clinical Disputes, justice.gov.uk (paras 1 to 6, Annexes A to C)
- Practice Direction – Pre-Action Conduct and Protocols
- CPR Part 36: offers to settle (para 3.21 of the protocol)
The Annex C wording is Crown copyright, reproduced under the Open Government Licence v3.0.