How to use the Points of Dispute builder
- Choose your side. Drafting Points of Dispute for the paying party, or Replies for the receiving party to Points already served.
- Fill in the heading. The court, the claim number and the parties, as on the bill, and which party serves the Points.
- Enter the date of service. The method and date the notice of commencement (or the Points of Dispute) was served: the builder gives the deemed date of service and the 21-day date.
- Add the Points. For each Point: whether it is a general point, a point of principle or about specific items, the bill item numbers, the objection and, optionally, the figures claimed and offered. Replying, copy each Point in as served and add your Reply and any concession.
- Check and download. Work through the checks, read the preview in the Precedent G layout, then download it as a Word document or copy it as text.
The Precedent G format
Precedent G, headed “Points of Dispute”, is the model form in the Schedule of Costs Precedents annexed to PD 47 (PDF on justice.gov.uk). It sets out:
- The heading: the court, the claim number and the parties, then a title naming the party serving them, such as “Points of Dispute served by the Defendant”.
- One box for each Point: the left-hand box gives the Point’s number and either “General point”, “Point of principle” or the numbers of the bill items it concerns, such as “(6), (12), (17)”; the right-hand box gives the objection and, in the examples, what should be allowed.
- Two rows under each Point: “Receiving Party’s Reply” and “Costs Officer’s Decision”. The decision is for the court: on a provisional assessment it notes its decisions on the completed Precedent G and returns it (PD 47 para 14.4(2)).
- The last line: the date of service and who served them, “[legal representative of] the Defendant”.
The builder keeps that layout and those labels. For Replies it adds “and Replies of [the receiving party]” to the title and a “Replies served on” line at the end, which Precedent G does not show. Precedent G lists separate item numbers; writing a run of items as “(23) to (29)” is our style. Because the paying party may be either side, and any other party to the proceedings may serve Points too (CPR 47.9(1)), you choose who serves them and who the receiving party is. Precedent G has no columns for figures; if you enter them, the builder can print them as a last line in each box, and it totals them on screen only.
What Points of Dispute must contain (PD 47 paras 8.2 and 8.3)
Points of Dispute must be short and to the point, and must follow Precedent G so far as practicable. They must identify any general points or matters of principle which require decision before the individual items in the bill are addressed, and identify specific points, stating concisely the nature and grounds of dispute. Once a point has been made it should not be repeated: the item numbers where it arises go in the left-hand box (para 8.2). The paying party must state in an open letter accompanying them what sum, if any, it offers to pay in settlement of the total costs claimed, and may also make a Part 36 offer (para 8.3).
Against an electronic bill, the SCCO Guide 2025 asks that Points of Dispute, so far as practicable, categorise the items objected to, for example by legal team member, task, activity or communication, so the court can filter the bill; if they do not, the court may order them to be redrawn (para 11.2). The builder accepts a reference of that kind in place of item numbers.
Ainsworth and Ward v Rai: why specific points matter
In Ainsworth v Stewarts Law LLP [2020] EWCA Civ 178, a solicitor and own client assessment, the Court of Appeal held that the receiving party and the court must be able to tell why an item is disputed: specific points, the items they relate to and why ([39]). A point that said all items were disputed, gave no item numbers and no reasons did not comply with para 8.2 or take the form of Precedent G ([42]). In Ward v Rai [2026] EWCA Civ 816 the court restored a costs judge’s decision not to strike out a vague point, as within his discretion ([58] and [60]), but warned that paragraph 8.2 requires an Ainsworth compliant approach, and that non-compliant points risk being struck out or, as a minimum, costs sanctions ([61]). Our case note on Ward v Rai sets out the decision. The builder flags blanket wording, Points with no item numbers and long Points, but whether a Point is specific enough is for you and, in the end, the court.
Replies to Points of Dispute (CPR 47.13; PD 47 para 12)
The receiving party may serve a Reply on the other parties within 21 days after being served with the Points of Dispute (CPR 47.13). It must be limited to points of principle and concessions only, and must not contain general denials, specific denials or standard form responses (PD 47 para 12.1). Whenever practicable it must be set out in the form of Precedent G (para 12.2): the builder prints each Reply in the Reply row under the Point it answers, keeping the Points’ numbers and order as served. It flags wording such as “denied” or “maintained”, and identical Replies to different Points, which on our reading may be the denials and standard form responses para 12.1 excludes. A copy of any Replies served goes to the court with the request for an assessment (PD 47 para 13.2(f)). Our guide to Points of Dispute and Replies covers how to reply, with a worked example.
The 21-day dates
The builder works out the deemed date of service of the document that starts the clock (CPR 6.26: for example, an email sent on a business day before 4.30pm is served that day, and first class post on the second day after posting if that is a business day, or else the next business day) and counts 21 days from it, with the latest send dates to be deemed served in time. It does not handle service outside England and Wales (PD 47 para 5.4). For the whole timetable, from the costs order to the final costs certificate, use the detailed assessment deadline calculator.
What the builder does not do
It does not write objections or Replies, suggest reductions, or say whether a Point will succeed: it lays out, numbers and totals what you write, and checks the form. The totals add up the figures you typed; Points can overlap (a general point on rates touches every item), so they are not the value of the bill, and they are not the para 8.3 offer, which is made in an open letter.
Sources
- CPR Part 47 (rules 47.9, 47.13 and 47.14) and Practice Direction 47 (paras 5.4, 8.1 to 8.3, 10.1, 12.1, 12.2, 13.2, 13.10 and 14.4)
- Precedent G, Schedule of Costs Precedents
- CPR Part 6 (rule 6.26)
- Ainsworth v Stewarts Law LLP [2020] EWCA Civ 178 at [37] to [44], and Ward v Rai [2026] EWCA Civ 816 at [19], [20] and [58] to [61]
- SCCO Guide 2025 (paras 11.1 to 11.3)