How to use the VAT on costs checker
- Say who did the legal work. Solicitors or other lawyers the receiving party pays (and whether they charged UK VAT), its own employed lawyers (including a Government Department’s legal staff), the party itself in person, or pro bono lawyers under a s.194(3) order.
- Give its VAT position. Whether it is a public body that gets VAT refunded, whether it is registered for VAT on its own or in a VAT group, whether the legal services were for its business, and how much of the VAT on these costs it can recover.
- Say how the costs are worked out. Assessed costs, fixed costs under CPR 45.2, Section II fixed issue, judgment or enforcement costs, or IPEC scale costs.
- Add figures (optional). Profit or fixed costs, counsel’s fees, your own travel and postage, VAT charged on disbursements and court fees, all net of VAT.
- Read the answer. Whether VAT can be claimed and how much, the VAT on each item, and the certificate and bill requirements.
The rule: VAT the receiving party cannot recover
“VAT should not be included in a claim for costs if the receiving party is able to recover the VAT as input tax. Where the receiving party is able to obtain credit from HMRC for a proportion of the VAT as input tax, only that proportion which is not eligible for credit should be included in the claim for costs” (PD 44 para 2.3). The receiving party is responsible for claiming VAT only when it cannot recover it (para 2.4). Input tax means VAT on services supplied for the purpose of a business carried on by the person (VAT Act 1994 s.24(1)). HMRC first asks whether the legal services were for the business or for someone in a personal capacity, and there must normally be a direct connection between the substance of the dispute and the business’s activities (VIT13600). So a private individual usually claims the VAT, and a fully taxable business that litigated for its business usually does not. The paying party cannot reclaim VAT on the other side’s costs, because the costs order is not payment for a supply to it (VIT13600; VATSC11531).
Where the legal services were used partly for the business, only the business share of the VAT is input tax (VAT Act 1994 s.24(5)). A company in a VAT group recovers input tax through the group, so it counts as registered (s.43(1)). A council or other body under s.33 gets VAT on its non-business costs refunded whether or not it is registered, and a government department or NHS body gets VAT refunded on listed services, which for departments include the conduct of civil litigation (s.41(3); HMRC VATGPB10770): PD 44 para 2.3 speaks of input tax, but costs are an indemnity, so in our reading a body that gets the VAT back should not claim it (para 2.4). In insurer-funded and subrogated claims, the legal services are supplied to the insured, so it is the insured’s VAT position that counts (HMRC VIT13500; VAT Notice 701/36 para 5.2).
If the VAT is disputed: Precedent F(6)
Where there is a dispute about whether VAT is properly claimed, the receiving party must provide a certificate signed by its legal representatives or auditors, substantially in the form of Precedent F (PD 44 para 2.5). Certificate (6) states, on the basis of the receiving party’s last completed VAT return, whether it would be entitled to recover the VAT, or only a stated percentage of it, as input tax under s.24 of the VAT Act 1994. It is optional otherwise, and can go in the bill or be served later as a supplementary document (Precedent F; PD 47 para 13.10). A litigant in person claiming VAT must produce evidence, such as a letter from HMRC, at the hearing (PD 44 para 2.5).
Fixed costs and scale costs
“Where appropriate, VAT may be recovered in addition to the amount of fixed costs in rules 45.8 and 45.15A and Section IV, Section VI, Section VII, Section VIII or Section X of this Part and any reference to fixed costs in those Sections is a reference to those costs net of any such VAT” (CPR 45.2, as amended by SI 2024/839 from 1 October 2024; the text on justice.gov.uk is garbled, so read it on legislation.gov.uk). VAT on allowable disbursements in those regimes may be added too (CPR 45.57(3)). Part 45 makes no provision for VAT on the Section II fixed issue, judgment and enforcement costs: rule 45.16(1) allows only the sums in that Section unless the court orders otherwise (with court fees added by r.45.16(4)), and r.45.2 does not mention Section II, so the checker does not add VAT to them. In the Intellectual Property Enterprise Court, VAT may be recovered in addition to scale costs where appropriate, and the scale costs are net of it (CPR 46.21(6)).
Disbursements, travel and court fees
Court fees are passed on as disbursements, with no VAT added (PD 44 para 2.11(6); HMRC VTAXPER46000). A payment counts as a disbursement for VAT only if the supply was made to the client and the conditions in VAT Notice 700 para 25.1.1 are met; any VAT the supplier charged, such as an expert’s, then stays part of the disbursement and is claimable between the parties only if the receiving party cannot recover it. If the supplier’s service was supplied to the firm rather than the client, it is not a disbursement for VAT, and VAT is added at 20% on the whole amount, whether or not the supplier charged VAT (PD 44 para 2.11(3) and (4)). The firm’s own travel, meals, postage and telephone are part of its own supply, so VAT is added to them (para 2.11(2) and (5)), where they are allowed at all: between the parties, postage, telephone calls and local travel are in general not allowed (PD 47 para 5.22(3) and (4)).
Where no VAT is claimed
No VAT on a litigant in person’s own work, even if they are a solicitor (PD 44 para 2.12); none on an employer’s own employed lawyers’ work, because an employee’s services are not a supply (HMRC VATSC11533 para 4), and none on costs paid to a Government Department for its own legal staff (para 2.13); none in a bill under a pro bono order under s.194(3) of the Legal Services Act 2007 (para 2.14); and none where the lawyers charged no UK VAT, as for a client who belongs outside the UK (VAT Act 1994 s.7A; Sch 4A para 16). Where the VAT rate changes during the work, the bill is split, and the lower rate is assumed to have been elected unless something in writing says otherwise (paras 2.7 to 2.9); the standard rate has been 20% since 4 January 2011.
Related tools
- The statement of costs: the N260 builder
- The certificates: the costs forms and precedents guide, for Precedent F
- Fixed costs: the fixed issue, judgment and enforcement costs lookup
- Every free tool in one place: costs help for solicitors
Sources
- Practice Direction 44, paras 2.1 to 2.14; Precedent F (certificates), annexed to PD 47; Practice Direction 47, paras 5.22 and 13.10
- CPR 45.2 (as amended from 1 October 2024); CPR 45.16 (Section II); CPR 45.57; CPR 46.21
- VAT Act 1994, s.24; VAT Act 1994, ss.33 and 41(3); VAT Act 1994, s.43 (VAT groups); VAT Act 1994, s.7A and Sch 4A para 16; VAT Regulations 1995, regs 101 and 106
- HMRC VIT13500 (insurers and legal services); HMRC VAT Input Tax manual, VIT13600 (legal expenses); HMRC VAT Supply and Consideration manual, VATSC11531; HMRC VATSC11533 (employed solicitors); HMRC VATSC11534 (the agreement with the Law Society); HMRC VATGPB4405 and VATGPB10770 (public bodies’ refunds); HMRC VTAXPER46000 (solicitors’ disbursements); VAT Notice 700, para 25 (disbursements); VAT Notice 733, para 15.2 (Flat Rate Scheme); VAT Notice 701/36, para 5.2 (insurance); GOV.UK, VAT rates