The rule: CPR 44.2(8)
“Where the court orders a party to pay costs subject to detailed assessment, it will order that party to pay a reasonable sum on account of costs, unless there is good reason not to do so.”
The rule applies when the court makes an order for costs to be assessed by detailed assessment. Where costs are assessed summarily, the court fixes the figure there and then. Once the receiving party has filed a request for a detailed assessment hearing, the court can also issue an interim costs certificate (CPR 47.16), and when it sets aside a default costs certificate it can attach conditions and order a payment on account (PD 47 para 11.3). For the wider question of interim payments of damages and costs, see our guide to interim payment percentages; for a worked example of the reasoning, our note on Cubic v TfL.
What courts have ordered
These are each court’s findings on its own evidence, not benchmarks. Read the “share” column with care: the percentage is of a different base in almost every case.
| Case | Basis and budget | Costs, sought and offered | Ordered | Share, and of what | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cleveland Potash Ltd v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP) High Court, Master Kaye sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, 30 October 2026 · our note | Standard. Not budgeted: a phase-by-phase schedule | Costs claimed £1,204,160.86; sought £700,000; the first respondent proposed a figure based on 30% ([153]) | £550,000 ([186]) | About 46% of the costs claimed (our arithmetic: the court set a sum, not a percentage) | Costs and the sum sought on the high side, with phases that appeared to include irrecoverable costs, but 30% too low; £550,000 left substantial headroom ([185] to [187]). |
| Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon OBE and others v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2026] EWHC 2207 (KB) High Court, Nicklin J, 21 August 2026 · our note | Indemnity. Costs managed: approved budgeted costs plus incurred pre-budget costs | Sought 90% of budgeted and 65% of pre-budget costs; the claimants accepted 90% of budgeted costs and offered 40% of pre-budget costs ([185] and [186]) | £9,544,355, by 28 August 2026 ([189] and [191]) | £4,669,127.10 (90% of approved budgeted costs, conceded) plus £4,875,228.24 (60% of incurred pre-budget costs), rounded down to the pound ([189]) | Exceptionally large costs justified a substantial margin on the pre-budget costs, but the indemnity basis supported more than the claimants offered ([188] and [189]). |
| Car-Wizard Ltd v Vixen Surface Treatments Ltd [2026] EWHC 2177 (Ch) High Court, HHJ Paul Matthews sitting as a Judge of the High Court, 17 August 2026 · our note | Indemnity. Costs managed: budget estimated costs £146,668, budget incurred costs £148,244 | Costs order: 90% of the claimant’s costs ([35]); sought £236,000 (90% of estimated, 70% of incurred); the defendant suggested 50% ([46]) | £214,000 ([46]) | 80% of the budget estimated costs and 65% of the budget incurred costs, with the 90% costs order folded into the choice | Costs on the indemnity basis throughout ([36] and [41]). The approved (estimated) figure is more robust than the incurred figure, which the court does not approve, so the margin on incurred costs is bigger ([45] and [46]). |
| Abbott and others v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2083 (KB) High Court, Garnham J, with Master Brown as assessor, 7 August 2026 · our note | Standard. Common costs in group litigation; no signed draft bill or certified schedule | Common costs £9,738,983.15, less £1,355,000 already paid on account; the claimants sought 65%, the Ministry suggested 36% ([73] and [74]) | £2,515,194.95 ([79]) | 50% of the costs recoverable under a 60% costs order, after deducting the earlier payment: 50% × 60% × £8,383,983.15 | Real concerns about rates, hours, seniority, delegation and disbursements without certified figures; a broad-brush estimate with a margin of error; the paying party was good for the money and a further interim certificate was possible ([75] to [78]). The judge invited further submissions on the mathematics if the figures were not agreed ([80]), so the order of the steps is not settled. |
| Cubic Transportation Systems Ltd v Transport for London [2026] EWHC 211 (TCC) Technology and Construction Court, Mr Roger ter Haar KC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, 5 February 2026 · our note | Not stated (standard by default, CPR 44.3(4)). Costs of an interim application (to lift the automatic suspension) and of an application for expedition | Costs claimed £1,201,444.75; sought £720,866.85; the paying party offered no more than £300,000 ([7] and [8]) | £720,866.85, the full sum sought ([14]) | 60% of the costs claimed | No fixed percentage ([11] and [12]); high-value procurement, heavy evidence, the counsel teams, and the paying party’s own costs of £1,182,020.75 ([13]). |
| Harlequin Property (SVG) Ltd v Wilkins Kennedy [2016] EWHC 3233 (TCC) Technology and Construction Court, Coulson J, 21 December 2016 | Standard. No costs management ([48]) | Draft bill just over £5.1 million; costs order 60%; the paying party argued for 30% ([43], [44] and [49]) | £2 million, paid into court until further order ([50]) | Two thirds of the roughly £3 million recoverable under the 60% order | No general rule of 40% to 50% of the bill; general parity with the paying party’s own £4.7 million costs gave confidence ([49]). The judge applied the Mars v TeKnowledge test (a figure he was confident would not exceed the assessed costs), the approach Excalibur declined to treat as the test ([22]). |
| Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc [2015] EWHC 566 (Comm) Commercial Court, Christopher Clarke LJ, 3 February 2015 | Indemnity. Not budgeted: litigation the judge called gargantuan; the paying parties were the funders of the losing claimant | Earlier estimate of recovery on the indemnity basis: 85% of the costs claimed ([25]) | 80% of the costs claimed ([25] and [28]) | 80% of the costs claimed (the 85% estimate less a margin for error) | A reasonable sum is often an estimate of the likely recovery less a margin for error ([23]); the factors at [24]; little risk in recovering any overpayment ([28]). |
| Thomas Pink Ltd v Victoria’s Secret UK Ltd [2014] EWHC 3258 (Ch) High Court, Birss J, 31 July 2014 | Not stated (standard by default, CPR 44.3(4)). Approved budget £678,009.10 ([51]); the claimant sought £644,829 ([52]) | The paying party suggested about £350,000 ([57]) | 90% of £644,829.10, rounded up to the nearest thousand ([60]): about £581,000 on our arithmetic | 90% of £644,829.10, the costs to date claimed within the approved budget | An approved budget will not be departed from without good reason, which has a very significant impact on the sum on account ([60]). The judge used the “irreducible minimum” approach ([58]), which Excalibur at [22] declined to treat as the test. |
Two cases with almost the same costs claimed, about £1.2 million, show why the percentage is an output of the evidence: 60% in Cubic, and about 46% in Cleveland Potash, where the judge could point to specific costs that might not survive assessment. Our Cleveland Potash note goes through the phase-by-phase reasoning, and our Abbott note the figures behind the 50%.
How a reasonable sum is worked out
In Excalibur Ventures v Texas Keystone the court said that any sum will have to be an estimate, and that a reasonable sum would often be an estimate of the likely level of recovery subject to an appropriate margin for error, for example by taking the lowest figure in a likely range or deducting from a single estimate ([23]). It rejected the older “irreducible minimum” test as the criterion ([22]), and the courts in Cleveland Potash ([149]) and Lawrence ([186]) followed that approach. The calculator mirrors those steps:
- Start from the costs claimed: incurred and budgeted costs apart where there is a costs management order.
- Take off, as a scenario, any costs the paying party says cannot be recovered at all.
- Apply the costs order’s share, if it is for a percentage of the costs.
- Apply the percentages you want to test, which stand for the likely recovery less a margin.
- Take off any payment already made on account, from the costs first (as in Abbott) or from the result.
The factors the court weighs
- Likely recovery. The level of the costs against the court’s provisional view of what is reasonable and proportionate (Cubic at [11]), and any costs that may not be recoverable at all, such as costs covered by another order (Cleveland Potash at [176]).
- The information. The receiving party must give enough to make a safe order (Cleveland Potash at [152]). In Abbott the absence of a signed draft bill or certified schedule, with concerns about rates, hours, seniority, delegation and disbursements, led to 50% where 65% was sought ([75] and [78]).
- The budget. On a standard basis assessment, approved or agreed budgeted costs are departed from only for good reason (CPR 3.18); incurred costs are not approved (CPR 3.17), so courts keep a bigger margin on them (Car-Wizard at [45]).
- The basis of assessment. Indemnity costs supported higher sums in Excalibur ([25]) and Lawrence ([189]).
- Comparisons and conduct. The paying party’s own costs can be informative (Cubic at [13]; Harlequin at [49]), and so can the way the case was run: in Excalibur, where the funders of the losing claimant were ordered to pay, the court bore in mind the work generated by the way the claimant and its solicitors conducted the litigation before and after trial ([25]).
- Risk. Any difficulty in recovering the costs, the likelihood of an appeal, the parties’ means, how soon the assessment will be, and whether an overpayment could be recovered (Excalibur at [24] and [28]; Abbott at [77]).
When it must be paid, interest and what follows
A party must comply with an order for the payment of costs within 14 days of the date of the order if it states the amount, or by such other date as the court may specify (CPR 44.7). CPR 40.11 says the same of any order for the payment of an amount of money (including costs). After Part 36 acceptance, where no order on account is available, an interim costs certificate is payable within 14 days of the certificate (CPR 44.7(1)(b)). The calculator counts 14 days from the order or certificate, without moving a date that falls at a weekend or on a bank holiday. Interest on costs runs from the date of the order on the sum eventually found due; a payment on account, once made, reduces the exposure to interest (Cleveland Potash at [199]): our interest on costs calculator allows for payments on account. The detailed assessment deadline calculator covers the steps that follow, and the glossary has the definition of a payment on account.
Sources
- CPR Part 44: General Rules about Costs (rules 44.2(6)(g), 44.2(8), 44.3(3) and 44.7), read on 18 November 2026. Practice Direction 44 was also read: it says nothing about payments on account.
- CPR Part 47 (rule 47.16) and Practice Direction 47 (paras 11.3, 15 and 16.12), read on 18 November 2026
- CPR Part 3 (rules 3.17 and 3.18), read on 18 November 2026
- CPR Part 40 (rules 40.8 and 40.11), read on 18 November 2026, and the Judgments Act 1838, s.17
- Cleveland Potash Ltd v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy [2026] EWHC 2781 (BP) (High Court, Master Kaye sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, 30 October 2026), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Baroness Lawrence of Clarendon OBE and others v Associated Newspapers Ltd [2026] EWHC 2207 (KB) (High Court, Nicklin J, 21 August 2026), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Car-Wizard Ltd v Vixen Surface Treatments Ltd [2026] EWHC 2177 (Ch) (High Court, HHJ Paul Matthews sitting as a Judge of the High Court, 17 August 2026), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Abbott and others v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWHC 2083 (KB) (High Court, Garnham J, with Master Brown as assessor, 7 August 2026), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Cubic Transportation Systems Ltd v Transport for London [2026] EWHC 211 (TCC) (Technology and Construction Court, Mr Roger ter Haar KC sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, 5 February 2026), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Harlequin Property (SVG) Ltd v Wilkins Kennedy [2016] EWHC 3233 (TCC) (Technology and Construction Court, Coulson J, 21 December 2016), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Excalibur Ventures LLC v Texas Keystone Inc [2015] EWHC 566 (Comm) (Commercial Court, Christopher Clarke LJ, 3 February 2015), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Thomas Pink Ltd v Victoria’s Secret UK Ltd [2014] EWHC 3258 (Ch) (High Court, Birss J, 31 July 2014), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026
- Finnegan v Spiers [2018] EWHC 3064 (Ch) (High Court, Birss J, on appeal, 27 June 2018), Find Case Law, read on 18 November 2026: CPR 44.2(8) does not apply where costs follow acceptance of a Part 36 offer within the relevant period, because no court has ordered costs ([31] and [32]).