How a success fee is worked out
A conditional fee agreement provides for the solicitor’s fees, or part of them, to be payable only in specified circumstances, usually if the claim succeeds. A success fee is the amount by which the fees are increased above what would be payable if it were not a CFA (s.58(2)). It is a percentage of the base costs, not of the damages: a 50% success fee on base costs of £10,000 is £5,000, plus VAT where VAT is charged. Counsel instructed under their own CFA has a separate success fee.
The personal injury cap
For a claim for personal injuries, the CFA must say that the success fee is subject to a maximum, expressed as a percentage of specified damages (s.58(4A) and (4B); CFA Order 2013, art 4). The most it can be is:
| Agreement and proceedings | Cap | Measured against |
|---|---|---|
| CFA, personal injury, first instance | 25% (art 5(1)(a)); the calculator treats it as including VAT, the cautious reading | General damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, and past pecuniary loss, net of sums recoverable by the CRU (art 5(2)) |
| CFA, personal injury, all other proceedings (appeals) | 100% (art 5(1)(b)) | The same damages |
| CFA, any other claim | No cap on damages; the success fee is at most 100% of base costs (art 3) | Base costs |
| DBA, personal injury, first instance | 25%, including VAT (reg 4(2)(b)) | The same damages as the CFA cap; the payment can only come from them (reg 4(2)(a)) |
| DBA, other claims, first instance | 50%, including VAT (reg 4(3)) | The sums ultimately recovered by the client |
| DBA, employment matter | 35%, including VAT (reg 7) | The sums ultimately recovered by the client |
| DBA, appeals (other than employment) | No cap in the Regulations (reg 4(4)) | - |
The cap does not apply to a CFA entered into before 1 April 2013 for the matter, or under which services were provided before that date (art 6(1)), to a claim for damages for diffuse mesothelioma, to publication and privacy proceedings, or to proceedings brought by a liquidator, trustee in bankruptcy or administrator, or by a company in liquidation or administration (art 6(2)). The 25% limits the success fee only: base costs the other side does not pay are a matter for the CFA, and many CFAs limit the total taken from damages.
What the other side pays
For CFAs entered into on or after 1 April 2013, a costs order may not require one party to pay another party’s success fee (s.58A(6)), subject to the exceptions above for older CFAs, insolvency office-holders, publication and privacy proceedings and diffuse mesothelioma. The winning client can still recover base costs, subject to assessment and the indemnity principle: the other side need not pay more than the client is liable to pay its own solicitor. Interest on costs before judgment is a separate question: see our note on Mariana v BHP, which does not make success fees recoverable. Under a DBA, recoverable costs are assessed in the usual way but cannot be more than the total the client owes under the DBA for legal services (CPR 44.18(2)), and outside employment matters whatever the other side pays reduces the client’s payment (reg 4(1)).
Worked examples
1. Personal injury, first instance, CFA made in 2025. Base costs £12,000 plus VAT, success fee 100%: £12,000.00 plus £2,400.00 VAT. Damages: £12,000 general damages, £6,000 past loss, £4,000 future loss, with £1,500 of benefits deducted by the CRU. The cap is 25% of £12,000 + £6,000 − £1,500 = £16,500.00, so £4,125.00. The success fee is cut by £10,275.00, and the client pays £4,125.00 with VAT. The other side pays none of it; the client keeps £16,375.00 of the £20,500.00 damages after the CRU deduction, before any other deductions.
2. A commercial claim, CFA made in 2024. 20 hours at £300 and 35.5 hours at £180 make base costs of £12,390.00. A 50% success fee is £6,195.00, with VAT £7,434.00. There is no damages cap, and the success fee cannot be recovered from the other side; the base costs can, subject to assessment.
3. A DBA in a contract claim, first instance. The client recovers £80,000 and agreed to pay 40%, including VAT: £32,000.00, under the 50% cap of £40,000.00. The other side pays £18,000 in costs, so the client pays £14,000.00 (reg 4(1)(a)), and the other side could not have been ordered to pay more than £32,000.00 in costs (CPR 44.18(2)(b)).
The client’s rights
A success fee is part of the solicitor’s bill to the client. The client can usually ask the court to assess the bill under s.70 of the Solicitors Act 1974; if the agreement is a contentious business agreement, the client instead asks the court to examine it, and the court can reduce it or set it aside if it is unfair or unreasonable (ss.60(1), 61). Use the Solicitors Act assessment checker for the time limits. On an assessment the court considers the percentage increase on all the relevant factors as they reasonably appeared when the CFA was entered into or varied (CPR 46.9(4)). Costs are assessed on the indemnity basis, with rebuttable presumptions: costs the client approved are presumed reasonable, and costs of an unusual nature or amount are presumed unreasonable unless the client was told they might not be recovered from the other side (CPR 46.9(3); PD 46 paras 6.1 and 6.2). In county court proceedings, s.74(3) of the Solicitors Act limits the bill to what could have been allowed between the parties unless a written agreement expressly permits more (CPR 46.9(2)). For a child or protected party, deductions from damages need the court’s approval: see the CPR 21.10 approval checklist.
Sources
- Courts and Legal Services Act 1990, s.58, s.58A and s.58AA, read on 18 November 2026
- The Conditional Fee Agreements Order 2013 (SI 2013/689), arts 2 to 6 and the Explanatory Note; and the Conditional Fee Agreements Order 2000 (SI 2000/823), art 4
- The Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013 (SI 2013/609), regs 1, 4 and 7, read on 18 November 2026
- Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012, s.44 (with its commencement notes) and s.48
- CPR Part 44 (rule 44.18), CPR Part 46 (rule 46.9), Practice Direction 46 (paras 6.1 to 6.4), CPR Part 48 (rule 48.2) and CPR Part 21 (rule 21.12)
- Solicitors Act 1974, s.70 and s.74
- Social Security (Recovery of Benefits) Act 1997, s.8 and Schedule 2